if we are considering moving, we should also consider and evaluate other platforms too, rather than just debating slack vs discord. (I know there are several slack clones out there, don't recall their names though)
I don't think there are many viable alternatives... many need self hosting and therefor at least some amount of hardware, support and adminstration. Also I think working mobile apps on iOS and Android are important.
@w4rl0ck Mobile app support is definitely important, I have both discord and slack on my phone, although slack is far easier to use on mobile for me.
@w4rl0ck if the admins were up for it I think it may be worth exploring some of the other options even if they require hosting. Obviously this depends on how much hardware, but most of these applications (at least the ones without a major audio component) should run just fine on a small server ($20 a month on linode would get you a 4gb server).
vrs last edited by vrs
If I would have to choose between slack and discord, I'd choose IRC on one of the big networks.
- open standard
- won't get fired for using it at work
- lots of clients to choose from (and some of them don't eat 2GB of RAM)
- no walled garden
- tons of integration options exist
- easy to archive
- can ignore others
- no signup required - much lower barrier of entry
- high nostalgia value, includes trout slapping
- not owned by a startup desperately trying to make money or go public before funding runs out
MrFaul last edited by
@tedivm Your webhook and git problems are already solved via bots...
Just pick the one which fits your bill. There are a ton out there.
We use a github bot for wiremod and it is awesome.
This is the public invite check how a working community looks like.
@vrs ironically we started on IRC but people really liked using Slack instead. That being said we had an IRC channel, not a network, but the features such as scrollback, notifications, pinned posts, and integrations were also a big factor in moving.
IRC is really bad for mobile devices and not nooby friendly.. to make irc useful (for offline messages for example) you need a bouncer... something that's not easy to run for everybody.
if you want you can use an IRC client to connect to slack.
CyberEd last edited by
I agree with WarInternal. I've used and love Discord for certain applications. Gaming with friends on FPS/RTS's is great, but it's a terrible choice for Screeps. Voice chat is the biggest "advantage" and serves no purpose here.
One of the nicest things about the current Slack setup is everything screeps related is in one place. No matter the obscure chat or group you're looking for, they have a channel. IMO this would end if we switched to discord. Individual sub-communities would create their own Discord/Slack channel splintering the community. For example, I found out about #ScreepsPlus by just browsing the channel list.
I also like to read Screeps on the go occasionally. I already have the Slack app installed for work. I'm not going to install the discord app solely for use with Screeps. I know personally I would be a lot less involved if it's moved to Discord.
This doesn't even touch on the fact we'd be giving up code snippets. No code snippet support for a programming game! There's no arguing Dicord has many great features, but it's a poor match for our use case.
Publiccert last edited by
I have no desire to switch to Discord. I run Slack at work and home and appreciate the fact that I can be signed into multiple accounts with it. The entire community is already entrenched in Slack. Why is this even a discussion? If we're having moderation users, promote some moderators. Slack is a privileges.
Slack. Easily the best option, the only downside is the history being lost. Otherwise its a clear winner vs discord.
deft-code last edited by
Is Slack's history horizon a function of the new message rate? Is there a way to see how much or our history each channel is consuming? The short history is a problem, but it feels like it's been worse lately.
I case you missed it. I'm in favor of keeping Slack. To me if feels like slack or some other programmer productivity chat app is the obvious choice. Screeps just doesn't fit well with near real time engagement on a gaming session that lasts a few hours. A much, much faster paced combat arena might benefit from a discord server, and a twitch stream. But even if a streamable game mode existed now Slack would still be the place where 3rd party tools and MMO strategies are discussed. I just don't see the realtime gaming chat client giving a worldwide community of developers what they need.
First, I'm not really a fan of the way the OP in this thread was worded. It seems clear you knew we have a Slack already, and went on to imply that it was just ridiculous that we don't use Discord. Well, we have a lot of reasons for using Slack, some good, some neutral, but mainly we already use Slack so you should have to give justification why we switch.
All new features start at -100 points. The entire community is on Slack right now - you want us all to move so you don't have to download a new app? The points in "favor" of Discord, apart from history (and history isn't exactly awesome on Discord) seem to be more like feature-parity. "Well, you can do $thing_you_like on Discord, too, except worse, with a bot, or a shitty interface (or both)." What are the advantages to moving? Because I don't see any. History is like +20 points, so you're still at -80.
I don't see why this is even a discussion. Slack has worked fine for years. We've had our share of malicious users - about one every couple months, from what I hear - and we just ban them. It hasn't been an issue. The user privileges on Discord are worse - you have to be a member of every public channel on the server, you can't create new public channels as a user, and if you want a channel that people aren't autojoined to (thinking of something like #exception-thrown on Slack) you have to write a bot to add/remove roles from people.
Finally, and in conclusion, Screeps is a land of contrasts.
No, but seriously, I do have one final point. There are many programming communities that use Slack - I'm a member of a couple of them. There are no programming communities that use Discord. Screeps is a game about programming. The sort of person that would play Screeps, but doesn't know how to use Slack and is unwilling to, seems like the kind of person that won't like Screeps for very long anyway. Or, if they do get into it, they'll learn to write code ... and then they'll probably join a slack community ... and now they have Slack open anyway.
Don't uproot an entire community (or stir everything up) because one guy is whining about having to open a second app. What the actual hell.
SemperRabbit last edited by
I also feel that discord is a bad idea for the screeps community. Slack has been going strong for over 2 years now. I am aware of at least 3 previous individuals that had complained and suggested discord as an alternative. Three previous times, it had been deemed a poor replacement. The lack of snippets alone is enough to get my non-concurrence. I agree with @Knightshade that we need an actual poll on what is important to the community. Snippets, integrations, channel creation, etc. I also disagree with the idea of everyone seeing what I'm playing. It feels like an invasion of privacy to me. I know I would be much less active in the community, and would probably step down as a moderator if it were migrated. I can have slack open at work. Discord would be a no-go.
My disagreement of migrating away from Slack aside, if a poll comes back and the majority of the community felt that a migration was needed, I would recommend considering something @daboross had mentioned in the most recent previous discussion about migrating off of slack: the Matrix protocol and riot.im. If they were to host a Matrix server hosting the global channels, they could hand admins the permissions to add additional servers to the federation. @ags131 could, for example, host a server in the federation that maintained S+ related channels and handled their history. All of the channels would be available regardless of what server they connect to. Any features that were lacking could be resolved by the community, as the server is open source, and the devs could host a fork of the code on the
screepsgithub that we could PR features into. Similarly, they provide APIs in multiple languages to connect to the server, so one could dev their own client if they do not like one of the existing ones, or fork an existing open source client to take advantage of any features PR'ed into the devs' fork. It would be very appropriate that the community had programmatic input on the server we chat on.
TL;DR: I am against moving away from slack; we need a poll to decide, not listen to the vocal minority; check out matrix protocol where we could dev the features we want for chat
UnFleshedOne last edited by
Another vote for slack, mainly because of NSFW nature of discord.
daboross last edited by daboross
- general chat
- official announcements
- webhooks to main project
- FAQ static channel
- Guild/Alliance list static channel
- private channels
- public channel for recruiting
- lots of custom channels
3rd Party Project Server
- support channels
- project github webhooks
If we had a structure like this, discord would make sense. However, Screeps by nature is not very alliance based, and "3rd party projects" account for over 80% of the traffic if that includes shared code relating to the game.
This is a game about programming, and slack's channel structure accommodates that. If we wanted to emphasize the "social network" aspect of the game, or alliances, maybe discord would work for that. But, at the moment, that's not what the community is about.
If we're talking about alternatives, and if at some point we decide slack's history is a killer (which it semi-is right now), I'd agree with SemperRabbit about https://riot.im/. Matrix has the advantages of IRC that @vrs and others have mentioned of being a free protocol, and with riot.im hosting we'd also have scrollback and other features slack provides over IRC.
Gankdalf last edited by
Something I wanted to point out. It was never actually my intention to cause a "switch" I was just surprised there wasn't a discord server already. The "switch" part happened when people started discussing that the community is too small to maintain both platforms. Being a bit of a newb at the social part of screeps at the moment, I wasn't previously aware that the community was small... although I probably should have guessed it, considering it is a programming game.
Friends, thank you all for your brilliant feeback on this topic. I think we'll conclude it this way:
We'll stick to Slack for the moment, but when Screeps Arena comes out, we'll create a Discord integration to leverage the social aspect of Arena battles (an ability to invite friends into matches, to join or spectate, etc), and then launch it as an experiment.
I'd like to stress it again - the whole Discord idea is not new, it has been debated by Screeps Team for a long time already, since the Discord GameBridge closed beta launch which could make it possible to create an in-game chat platform tied to world shards and sectors. It is discontinued now, but still, Rich Presence integration is a very desirable thing for a game like Screeps Arena (yes, basically it will be a separate game).
I know I'm late, and the decision has been made, but simply for the historical data, I'm 100% in favour of Discord. Slack's current limitations mean if I'm away for more than a few days I literally can't see channel history because it's being pruned. I've no major issue with staying with Slack, but could it be upgraded/paid for so that the history is readable? DIscord's archive is basically infinite, and completely searchable making that very powerful.
MrFaul last edited by
Ah crap I just realized I'm the one who threw the bad word "switch" in there which started to get people emotionally invested...
It was never my intention to abolish the slack channel it is just that I'm worried about the playerbase.\
Games in general thrive through a constant stream of new players (which in return leaves die hard fans) and for that you need publicity.
Discord and steam offer publicity through the "see what I'm doing" Paradigma which makes other people curious if they don't know the title.
A lot of people are scared when they read "game for programmers" and turn right away without giving it a chance to convince them. That's not the case if they are able to talk somebody first.
The whole this is better/worse discussion that followed is mostly personal preference even so it managed to sort some key points.
However there is one thing I want throw my 2¢ in there:
You are not supposed to play at work ( even if I'm guilty as well )
So that argument is rendered invalid by default! ( Only exception here is artch )
My vote is on discord. Slack may be more familiar to developers but the AWRyder that's playing screeps is the gamer one, not the programmer version.