Screeps Discord?
-
@gimmecookies My point exactly. Until we actually have some (or literally any, at this point) data, this is just a bunch of really shouty people in a room arguing over what color to paint the walls and whether to have regular conversations in Russian or Portuguese.
-
The one I linked in the original post as an example. It has been admin hidden behind a spoiler warning though, so you will have to click that to see it now.
Ah, cool!
If it has effective channels which can be joined/left and created by users, that solves my main objection.
Side note: I'm going to head to sleep, but I'll be back tomorrow. Hope the discussion goes well till then.
-
Observed issue with template: Doesn't appear to be a way to list joinable channels without joining them.
-
@knightshade You could try reading the list of channels. You must first accept the rules, and then you can join the listed channels.
-
@daboross said in Screeps Discord?:
If it has effective channels which can be joined/left and created by users, that solves my main objection.
I'm not sure I know a way for users to create channels that won't become very messy very quickly. Actually, I consider the number of channels in Slack to be very messy though, so I am not sure that opinion amounts to much.
-
You don't seem to understand the issue. I'm not failing to understand how to read.
I'm saying that I'm not convinced that the welcome page will be kept up to date.
EDIT: Since we're being snarky, you could try reading my comment rather than assuming I'm illiterate.
BONUS EDIT: .leaveall also doesn't appear to leave all. Not sure if deliberate or not.
-
@knightshade said in Screeps Discord?:
You don't seem to understand the issue. I'm not failing to understand how to read.
I'm saying that I'm not convinced that the welcome page will be kept up to date.
EDIT: Since we're being snarky, you could try reading my comment rather than assuming I'm illiterate.
By "list" you mean what exactly? I am a little confused why a list of joinable channels couldn't be kept up to date.
And sorry
-
@gankdalf You can always leave channels you dont like. Actually, you only see the channels you selected yourself. All other channels are hidden behind a button. So this is not really a issue.....
-
@gimmecookies By "messy" I meant I wasn't sure which channels to join and often seemed like there were multiple channels for each topic, which just ended up with 50 channels that nobody uses. I ended up subscribing to like half the channels just to see where the main activity on the server was.
-
@gankdalf said in Screeps Discord?:
@gimmecookies By "messy" I meant I wasn't sure which channels to join and often seemed like there were multiple channels for each topic, which just ended up with 50 channels that nobody uses. I ended up subscribing to like half the channels just to see where the main activity on the server was.
There is a indicator of the active members for each channel, and you can always take a look before you join a channel. The messy channel list is just something the discord likers will pull out of context. How is discord solving this issue?
-
@gimmecookies The indicator only displays the number of people in the channel, not how often it is used from what I can tell. It proved only useful for finding the obvious channels like #help and #general, which seems to be where most of the activity is anyways.
From what I can tell, most discord servers don't try to handle it at all, and simply leave all their channels enabled for everyone. Due to this (as others have stated), discord servers mostly have fewer channels.
There is also no default functionality that allows users (aka not the server owner or admins) to create more channels. They can create a new server, but not channels within a server. From what I have seen in other games, they tend to have one main server with around 10-20 general channels, and the alliances/guilds make their own servers and post them in a bulletin board channel in the main server.
-
@gankdalf said in Screeps Discord?:
@gimmecookies The indicator only displays the number of people in the channel, not how often it is used from what I can tell. It proved only useful for finding the obvious channels like #help and #general, which seems to be where most of the activity is anyways.
From what I can tell, most discord servers don't try to handle it at all, and simply leave all their channels enabled for everyone. Due to this (as others have stated), discord servers mostly have fewer channels.
There is also no default functionality that allows users (aka not the server owner or admins) to create more channels. They can create a new server, but not channels within a server. From what I have seen in other games, they tend to have one main server with around 10-20 general channels, and the alliances/guilds make their own servers and post them in a bulletin board channel in the main server.
So we get multiple servers with multiple channels. Looks like more mess to me?
-
Please, let's not fix what isn't broken.
Discord would be a step backwards.Let me be another shouty person in the room while we're waiting for a full fledged poll, survey or other data gathering.
#help: Discord is extremely unsuitable for the large code sharing that happens in, say, #help - by far the largest channel.
No line numbers, no expanding, no highlighting. Slack has all of these. #help constitutes about a third of all monthly messages. Let's not break that.
While Discord might be more accessible to join for new players, consider the net threshold for actually sticking with the game will probably go up because of the damage it does to #help.Voice: Discord's voice chat isn't a big advantage. Not only is the implementation terrible, reading out code isn't quite the best way to converse.
Voice chat also fragments the community in its own way (voice vs. no voice), for example the people joining the conversation during work downtime or non-natives who're not confident in their pronunciation. Voice chat's also aren't archived, while archiving is one of Discord's advantages people bring up.Archive: Speaking of archiving: when was the last time you really read back old messages? There's rarely ever anything I need to find back later, and in those rare occurrences you can just star the message for later. I doubt the archive is of much use. Especially given that a lot of the timeless data is on GitHub and the likes. Let the chat be timely and use other channels for timeless data.
There are many more reasons not to move to Discord, but I especially like to stress the impact on #help. I would absolutely loathe a move there, personally.
Finally, regarding @artch his point of integrating with Arena mode: if that's in 2019, there's no rush to move now. In a year, a lot can change, and Discord could be beaten by a better alternative. By the time those features actually have a visible impact for players they might become relevant, but let's not get ahead of ourselves.
-
Finally, regarding @artch his point of integrating with Arena mode: if that's in 2019, there's no rush to move now. In a year, a lot can change, and Discord could be beaten by a better alternative. By the time those features actually have a visible impact for players they might become relevant, but let's not get ahead of ourselves.
Sorry, it was a typo -- 2018 of course.
Also, although Rich Presence is useful mainly for Arena mode, it is not limited to that. We can display your shard there, the room you're observing, etc.
The discussion here is mostly about differences in Slack and Discord app features. But let's not forget that unlike Slack, Discord is more than an app - it's a social network. Rich Presence might be very beneficial to promote Screeps among Discord users who don't play Screeps yet, but are friends of Screeps players in some other games. Discord has some viral potential that we lack when using Slack as a standalone platform.
-
@keenathar said in Screeps Discord?:
#help: Discord is extremely unsuitable for the large code sharing that happens in, say, #help - by far the largest channel.
No line numbers, no expanding, no highlighting. Slack has all of these. #help constitutes about a third of all monthly messages. Let's not break that.
While Discord might be more accessible to join for new players, consider the net threshold for actually sticking with the game will probably go up because of the damage it does to #help.While discord doesn't have line numbers and no collapsing, it does have syntax highlighting.
And honestly I don't care about those other two...
Pasting more than a couple off snippets in a chat room isn't really helpful at all.
You can use tools like pastebin for that, discord will even give you a small preview for links.As artch already mentioned discord is a social network and as such a much better media than slack.
Don't get me wrong slack is a awesome tool on it's own but it is a tool for developing teams and not a instant messenger app even if it feels like one.Screeps is a game that can benefit from discords current features and with its constant grow and development most of the biggest gripes people have will be addressed eventually anyway.
The community support they offer is top I know that first hand. So talking to them is a option.Regarding the channel number my experience in moving a big community to discord is that it is plenty enough.
Most of what is discussed in slack is imo better of in this forum anyway.
-
@keenathar said in Screeps Discord?:
Archive: Speaking of archiving: when was the last time you really read back old messages? There's rarely ever anything I need to find back later, and in those rare occurrences you can just star the message for later. I doubt the archive is of much use. Especially given that a lot of the timeless data is on GitHub and the likes. Let the chat be timely and use other channels for timeless data.
As a returning player, I found it quite obnoxious that every channel other than #help and #general were unable to be read. All the channels were just blank. That's part of why I didn't understand which channels were active.
@gimmecookies said in Screeps Discord?:
@gankdalf said in Screeps Discord?:
@gimmecookies The indicator only displays the number of people in the channel, not how often it is used from what I can tell. It proved only useful for finding the obvious channels like #help and #general, which seems to be where most of the activity is anyways.
From what I can tell, most discord servers don't try to handle it at all, and simply leave all their channels enabled for everyone. Due to this (as others have stated), discord servers mostly have fewer channels.
There is also no default functionality that allows users (aka not the server owner or admins) to create more channels. They can create a new server, but not channels within a server. From what I have seen in other games, they tend to have one main server with around 10-20 general channels, and the alliances/guilds make their own servers and post them in a bulletin board channel in the main server.
So we get multiple servers with multiple channels. Looks like more mess to me?
I don't know if Slack can do this, but Discord can have custom bots to solve many of the functionality differences, including the user created channels if that is really something that they want to keep... I don't like that feature at all.
As for more more mess... the alliance channels always seemed odd to me. I have to go through and learn the names of every alliance, so that I can ignore their channels in discord. Having all of the alliances in their own servers would make it clearer which channels belonged to an alliance.
-
I agree with @daboross on his posts, trimming the channels down to the amount viable for discord would not be pleasant. I keep #general muted and rarely poke in because of the sheer number of messages all the time. I'm in a few discord servers, but rarely bother trying to participate due to way too much traffic. I don't have time to scroll through every channel to find out if anything is relevent when those channels have activity all day. In slack, the channels being spread out makes it much easier. I can see at a glance if I need to check in on something, for example, if #screepsplus or #screepsplus-support has unread, I will check them first to make sure theres no issues, others like #botarena or #swc I may ignore depending on if I'm busy or not. With discord this becomes much more annoying since so many conversations would end up merged.
I for one, would be much less active if we did move to discord, as others have mentioned they do, I work as a programmer, so have slack open anyway, during slow periods I'll check slack and chime in. I'm also afraid that if we did goto discord, it would end up fragmenting portions of the community, as alliances would be forced to create their own discord/slack/whatever server.
I also agree with @Knightshade here,
We're considering only two options. Seriously. We're taking a considerable hit to organization, group unity, etc. by moving regardless. The last thing I want is six months after a discord move to start hearing people talk about how ... is so much better and we need to move to that instead.
if we are considering moving, we should also consider and evaluate other platforms too, rather than just debating slack vs discord. (I know there are several slack clones out there, don't recall their names though)
-
@ags131 I'm still curious why discord isn't viable with more channels. I personally would prefer fewer channels just because I don't understand what more than half the channels in the Slack are even there for, but what is actually preventing discord from having the same number of channels as Slack?
-
@artch said in Screeps Discord?:
The discussion here is mostly about differences in Slack and Discord app features. But let's not forget that unlike Slack, Discord is more than an app - it's a social network. Rich Presence might be very beneficial to promote Screeps among Discord users who don't play Screeps yet, but are friends of Screeps players in some other games. Discord has some viral potential that we lack when using Slack as a standalone platform.
This, I believe, is one of the strongest considerations that has been raised so far. Some of the conversation has revolved around the notion that migrating from Slack to Discord would be inherently detrimental to the community, because it requires a change, new software, or whatever. But the fact is, there may be value to be gained from Discord that Slack does not offer. It may be an additional touch point for new players, and that, I think, is the holy grail.
-
If we move to discord we're going to need more moderators. As it is now the bulk of the "dealing with drama" is done pretty much by me (although it fortunately has been pretty quiet the last couple of months). As others have pointed out, having Slack open at work is pretty standard but having discord is not, so we'd need those extra moderators for all that time the existing mods would no longer be able to join the network.
Additionally, that whole point at the top- "Doesn't by default allow user-created channels"- would be pretty awful. We should not need admins to create channels for people.
